News: The 5-Second-Rule Is BS, Say Scientists

The 5-Second-Rule Is BS, Say Scientists

There's no reason to waste a perfectly good Cheeto just because it dropped on the kitchen floor, right? The "5-second-rule" makes it fair game if you can swipe it up fast enough (this doesn't apply for liquids or foods with floor fuzz stuck to them.) But, is that errant piece of chocolate really safe after it's mixed with the bacteria-laden mud from your shoe?

Scientists at Clemson University validate what we've always known—the longer the food stays on the ground, the more bacteria-infested it becomes. However, the team also found that 99% of bacteria was transferred onto food within the first 5 seconds. Bad news for the 5 second rule.

The scientists tested two different kinds of foods, bologna and bread, on three different kinds of surfaces: wood, tile, and carpet. In 5 seconds, wet bologna picked up a tiny bit more bacteria than dry bread. But, as it turns out, it matters less which kind of food you drop and more where you drop the food. Place determines not only how much bacteria but also what kind of bacteria get stuck on your munchies. Place matters.

Wood and tile were more effective at transferring bacteria than carpet, probably because they're smoother and have more area to touch your bologna sandwich. Certain germ-infested corners of your house give higher risk of making you ill like around your toilet and garbage can. That's why your dining room is separate from your kitchen and bathroom in the first place. But, there's some good news.

Unless you're floor is littered with garbage and dog poop, chances of your food landing in a super germ-infested area in your house is slim. That's why you mop every once in a while. Of course, any time any bacteria is transferred, there is risk of gastrointestinal sickness. But, if it's been a while since your last spring cleaning, you definitely don't want to take the 5-second-chance.

Want to master Microsoft Excel and take your work-from-home job prospects to the next level? Jump-start your career with our Premium A-to-Z Microsoft Excel Training Bundle from the new Gadget Hacks Shop and get lifetime access to more than 40 hours of Basic to Advanced instruction on functions, formula, tools, and more.

Buy Now (97% off) >

Other worthwhile deals to check out:

Photo by rhodyram

Join the Next Reality AR Community

Get the latest in AR — delivered straight to your inbox.


so funny, now that the five-second rule is officially in the oed:

Do we really need scientist to tell us the obvious? Im implementing the "no duh" rule.

Meh, won't change my habits of eating dropped food. I shalt not waste a good piece of food because of a little bacteria, gotta build up that immune system somehow.

Share Your Thoughts

  • Hot
  • Latest